Surfshark vs ProtonVPN: Which VPN Wins in 2026?

Surfshark and Proton VPN are VPNs with distinct approaches. Surfshark is known for being budget-friendly with unlimited devices and security extras including an antivirus. Proton VPN leans heavily on its Swiss privacy foundation, focusing on transparency through open-source apps and independent audits.

In this Surfshark vs Proton VPN comparison, we put both VPNs through real-world testing, measuring connection speeds, running leak tests, and attempting to access streaming platforms like Netflix. By the end, you’ll know which VPN earns your subscription – and which ultimately falls short.

Surfshark vs ProtonVPN: Quick Verdict and Key Differences

Need to make a quick decision? If privacy is your top priority, it’s hard to argue with Proton VPN. Choose Surfshark if you want the fastest speeds and best value.

Security, Privacy, and Jurisdiction Compared

Both VPNs use the WireGuard and OpenVPN protocols with effectively uncrackable ChaCha20 or 256-bit AES encryption. Where Proton VPN has the edge is its Swiss jurisdiction. Not only is this a country with strong privacy laws, it’s outside the Five Eyes intelligence alliance. Although Surfshark operates out of the Netherlands, which also has strong privacy protections, it’s part of Nine Eyes. Each operates a no-logs policy independently verified in multiple third-party audits.

Surfshark and Proton VPN each provide a kill switch and DNS leak protection. We stress-tested their kill switches and ran DNS and IP leak tests and both passed with no issues.

Proton VPN’s other significant advantage is open-source apps. Anyone can inspect the code, allowing for independent verification instead of relying on trust. That’s a genuine differentiator that very few VPNs match.

Speed, Server Network, and Performance Testing

What’s clear from our speed tests is that Surfshark and Proton VPN rank among the fastest VPNs. With Surfshark, we had speeds of up to 242 Mbps via the nearest local server. With Proton VPN, we recorded 239 Mbps via its EU servers. Overall, we had less speed loss with Surfshark – just 9.09% compared to 17.56% with Proton VPN.

I found speeds to be plenty fast enough for bandwidth-heavy activities including 4K streaming, torrenting, and playing online games. Provided you also have a solid base connection, my experience tells me you won’t have to encounter performance issues with either.

Proton VPN offers significantly more servers and locations. While Surfshark and Proton VPN have servers in the most sought after locations including the US and UK, Proton VPN’s larger network covering 127 locations makes it the better bet if you need a server in the Middle East or Africa.

Another advantage of Proton VPN covering more server locations is you’re more likely to find a server nearby for the fastest speeds. It also means more flexibility for sidestepping geographic restrictions.

Surfshark’s server network includes MultiHop servers which route traffic via two locations for an extra layer of encryption. Proton VPN’s Secure Core servers work similarly but route traffic via privacy-hardened countries like Iceland for even greater protection. Proton VPN also offers Tor Over VPN servers which route traffic through the Tor network — a feature with no direct equivalent on Surfshark, and a meaningful differentiator for high-stakes privacy use cases.

If you need a unique IP address, Surfshark offers an optional Dedicated IP add-on. Proton VPN’s Dedicated IP is business-only.

Streaming and Torrenting

Surfshark and Proton VPN don’t offer streaming-labeled servers but such is the strength of their blocking, they’re not missed. We recorded a 100% unblock rate with both, accessing Netflix, Prime Video, Disney+, and more at the first time of asking.

As for torrenting, Surfshark supports it across its whole server network. Proton VPN has specific P2P-enabled servers but also supports port forwarding, which can increase incoming connections and improve seeding efficiency.

Apps and Extra Features

There’s little to separate Surfshark and Proton VPN’s apps. Not only do they offer them for every major operating system, I found them straightforward to set up and use. If you do need help, both VPNs offer live chat support, albeit only Surfshark’s is available 24/7. Surfshark’s browser coverage is slightly wider, with a dedicated Edge extension that Proton VPN does not offer.

Some of the best VPNs nowadays can better be described as security suites, offering far more than VPN protection. In both cases, you’ll have access to ad blocking and breach monitoring.

However, there are a number of features that separate them. Only Surfshark offers an antivirus (available on the Surfshark One plan), a private browser, or identity protection. Proton VPN sets itself apart with its Unlimited plan which includes Proton’s password manager and cloud storage.

Pricing, Plans, and Overall Value for Money

You can choose between Surfshark and Proton VPN subscriptions of one month, one year, and two years. Although both VPNs have three tiers, Proton VPN’s base tier is its free VPN.

Proton VPN is significantly cheaper on a rolling monthly plan at $4.99 against Surfshark’s $15.45 — that’s a real difference if you only need a VPN for a few weeks or want to test before committing long-term. Surfshark’s one and two year plans are very close on price, with Surfshark coming in slightly cheaper at $2.49 a month compared to $2.99 on the long plan.

Surfshark’s unlimited simultaneous connections (against Proton VPN’s 10) and integrated antivirus help its value case at the long-plan tier. Proton VPN’s monthly price is the one place it clearly wins on value.

One more thing worth knowing about the refund window: Surfshark’s 30-day money-back guarantee is a full refund, while Proton VPN’s is prorated — you get back unused time, not the full amount paid. That’s a meaningful difference if you decide to cancel mid-subscription.

Surfshark vs Proton VPN: Which VPN Wins?

Surfshark and Proton VPN are close on most measures, and both are defensible choices. Proton VPN has more server locations, open-source apps, Swiss jurisdiction, and Tor Over VPN routing — the strongest privacy stack you’ll find in a mainstream paid VPN.

Surfshark wins this comparison on several fronts. It was faster across most of our test routes, with 9.09% speed loss against Proton VPN’s 17.56%. It allows unlimited simultaneous connections against Proton VPN’s 10, so the same subscription covers every phone, laptop, TV, and tablet in the household. Its 30-day money-back guarantee is a full refund, while Proton VPN’s is prorated. It includes integrated antivirus protection (via Surfshark One), a private browser, identity protection, and Alternative ID — features Proton VPN does not offer. 24/7 live chat support and a Microsoft Edge extension round out the convenience advantages.

For most users wanting a fast, full-featured VPN that covers their whole household, Surfshark is the call. For users where Swiss jurisdiction, open-source code verification, or Tor routing are non-negotiable, Proton VPN is the right pick.

Visit Surfshark.com

or read our full Surfshark review.

Frequently Asked Questions